Matt Cavanaugh wrote:mordacious1 wrote:deLurch wrote:
The church of satan will kill their plans every time.
SCOTUS has disproved a very old cliche'. Having christian-only prayers at these meetings is wrong. OTOH, if you throw in an occasional Rabbi, or Wiccan, or secularist...it's good and does not violate the Constitution. Therefore, several wrongs do make a right.
Could someone please explain the First Amendment to me in Barney terms -- or even better, by employing Muppets? I'm apparently otherwise incapable of understanding the Constitution.
Oh, and don't forget to repeatedly remind me of my stupidity, else I'll never agree with your interpretation.
Are you being sarcastic? In case you are not, here is the language in the First Amendment.
Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.
You can see the problem with this passage. It is pretty vague. What does it mean for Congress to make no law respecting an establishment of religion? This is the part that gets interpreted over and over.
A very conservative, but also honest, reading would suggest that Congress cannot pass a law declaring the US is a country of a certain religion.
A very liberal, but also honest, reading would suggest that Congress should use no governmental power to favor a certain religion.
So, really, tradition does come into play here. The more liberal justices think that the harm done to minorities is real and should be stopped. The more conservative justices think that traditional should be used as a guide, and that no specific religion is using government to coerce citizens.
Honest and thoughtful people can easily disagree on this. Now, as an atheist I line up with the liberals on this topic...but... I don't think the conservatives are monsters. (Well, maybe Scalia and Thomas are monsters...but not the others)
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Amen ... nstitution