HunnyBunny wrote:Are there any #AdoptDon'tShop pet adopting advocates here? I have a problem with this philosophy, but maybe I'm wrong.
To me this new movement that says pet breeding is wrong and people should never buy an animal as a pet is just a form of SJWism. It comes across as extremist and ill-informed. And sometimes plain dumb. However, I do acknowledge I am biased, having grown up with pedigree pets, and currently owning a dog of a specific breed, who we purchased from a registered breeder.
I have FFFs (Fucking Facebook Friends) who seem otherwise intelligent, but constantly post about how 'adopting' is the only ethical route to pet-owning. My objections are, in no particular order:
1. adoption (at least in France & UK) isn't free. In our part of France it costs €250, so these people are buying a pet.
2. along with the #adopt mantra, comes a plea to always neuter your pets. If all breeding should be stopped, and every pet is neutered then there will be no animals left. I can only assume that therefore these people are animal haters with the ultimate goal of removing cats and dogs from the face of the earth.
3. Many breeds have been around for hundreds, or in some case thousands, of years. No breeding would mean they all disappeared and only feral animals would be breeding, creating just one type of dog / cat / goldfish. I have found specific breeds can differ greatly from other breeds, and I wouldn't want to lose this diversity. Dogs used for jobs like care dogs, or sniffer dogs are specific breeds for a reason. Is it ok to breed those dogs still? Is it ok to breed horses - should we only adopt those as well because some people are mean to them or don't ethically breed them?
4. Animals in shelters are there because people, both breeders and owners, are stupid or mean or both. Only adopting animals won't stop people from being stupid or mean, it will just be that the nice people continue being nice, but with less opportunity to have a pet because there will be so few pets to go around. In short, it is people that are the problem, so perhaps we should do something about the people instead.
As I said, I acknowledge my love of certain breeds makes me biased. But also I hate extremists of any kind, and I am sceptical of the logic and claims made. If we didn't live in Hong Kong with the issue of no space, I probably would adopt a pet, along with the specific breed animals I like, if I found one that suited our family. I know that the recent rise in 'puppy farms' and unethical breeding for fashion traits is awful, but that comes back to people being a problem, and therefore we need to sort the people who are a problem.
So, any folk here who use the #adoptdon'tshop mantra care to put the other side?
Missed #2 - unless you plan on breeding your pet, always spay or neuter them. In many (most?) cases it can help with behavioral issues as well as help in lifespan and general health. Not sure why, perhaps stresses on the body? No clue, really, but many dogs live longer and have less of certain issues when spayed or neutered - I forget the specifics but it varies, and I'm not sure how extensive it really is. The behavioral issues, along with the problems with pets, especially cats, going into heat, and the costs of breeding an unwanted litter because you aren't responsible (letting them run around the neighborhood, etc) can be high. That part is also part of responsible ownership. If you keep your dog in the yard, for the most part, you won't have to worry about having a litter unexpectedly (depends on the breed, I've heard of large dogs jumping over shorter fences to consummate their one-night stands.
Also, the comment where you acknowledge the rise of puppy farms yet call that a problem with people - how do you deal with them if you support the industry that drives them? In some places animal care laws can stop such places if they are really bad and they get called in, yet many are skirting the line and nothing can be done. There are many ethical breeders (although with that you also have the problem with inbreeding which is a major problem with some breeds) but they don't normally sell to pet stores or advertise in the local paper, although dog or cat periodicals (esp the ones you normally don't find in bookstores) may have adverts. Dog shows are also good to find responsible breeders, although just being there doesn't make that true either.
I think maybe some of my views fit with what you were looking for, but I suspect they go further (at least with some people) but have no knowledge beyond what little I can surmise.