That's not exactly what Pinker said. He said that some intelligent, literate, media savvy people gravitate towards the alt-right because of some weaknesses of our approach to the alt-right. He didn't say that alt-righters as a whole are intelligent, literate people. It's like saying "some intelligent, literate, media savvy person may be recruited by ISIS propaganda", it doesn't mean that ISIS as a whole is made up of intelligent, literate people, or even that the average intelligence of an ISIS recruit is very high.feathers wrote: ↑Perhaps PZ's biggest gripe, though, is the statement that those alt-righters may very well be intelligent people.MacGruberKnows wrote: ↑Fri Jan 12, 2018 2:59 pmWhen Pinker claims that SJW's create their own antagonists called the Alt Right he is exactly correct. And Marx would agree with him. It's called dialectics. Guess what disco back in the 70's created? People who hated disco. If you tell me the job is not mine even though I am the best qualified because I'm a white male, guess what you just created? Correct. Another person who hates race-gender based hiring and advocates for merit hiring.
Myers can't tolerate any form of nuance, you're either with him or against him, you either consider everyone of your enemies to be not just wrong, but completely stupid and/or selfish, or you're working for the enemy. In doing so he often acts in a stupid way himself. For example he wrote that Pinker's talk is not about fighting the alt-right but only about blaming the left, then in the same paragraph he exposed Pinker's tactic to fight the alt-right, namely countering its narrative about some facts.
I think that PZ' biggest gripe is Pinker blaming academia for fucking up its approach to some themes (in a pretty gracious and non-judgmental way, but still). PZ can't stand the idea that he might have reacted in a different, more mature and clever way to people who criticized him. He hates being exposed as a bumbling asshole whose strategies to fight racism and prejudice in general are counterproductive, because this means he's crapped on his former acquaintances and alienate people for no reason.